Blog series Blogs Group blog Western Romance blog

Western Romance, The Story of Us – Part II

Mountain sunset cropped

In The Beginning by Lyn Horner

Western/Paranormal Author

My mom was a Minnesota girl. My dad hailed from Texas. I was born in San Francisco, California, where my parents met, but we moved to Minnesota when I was four years old so Mama could be near her family. For many years, I had no contact with my southern relations.

Yet, I came to love tales of Texas and the Old West thanks to my dad. With him, I watched every western he could find on TV. Later, he started me reading western novels, mainly those of Zane Gray.

Then, as a young married, I discovered the Romance Revolution – so named by Bertrice Small in a newsletter article she wrote in 2007 for Long Island Romance Writers. She was, of course, talking about the beginning of modern romance, in which she played a part. With this revolution came the birth of western romance, and once I discovered this genre, I was hooked.

Western historical romances arewagon train croppedgenerally set west of the Mississippi River, in the wild and wooly Old West. Most take place in the last half of the nineteenth century, although some are staged earlier. A few are now set in the early twentieth century, leading up to World War I. Together, they form a sub-genre of Historical Romance.

Historical Romance as we know it sprang to life thirty-nine years ago with the 1972 publication of The Flame and the Flower by Kathleen E. Woodiwiss.After her death in 2007, Ms. Woodiwiss’s editor, Carrie Feron, called her “the founding mother of the historical romance genre.” She wrote epic adventures with strong plots and character development, and she dared to include sizzling love scenes that went beyond a kiss and a hug. However, she was not the first to write western romances.

Rosemary Rogers claimed that honor with her first book, Sweet Savage Love,published in 1974. Whereas Woodiwiss often chose settings in far off lands and time periods, Rogers set SSL and numerous other books in the Old West. Her plots were highly dramatic, her characters’ actions sometimes hard to be believe, but that didn’t matter to her fans. And yes, I’m one of them. Maybe she was queen of the bodice rippers back then, but oh my, her heroes were men with a capital “M.”

Sweet Savage Loveset the stage for many other writers. My next guest blogger, Suzie Grant, will delve deeper into the topic of influential authors. Rather than intrude further into her territory, I sought out the roots of modern western romance, and what sets it apart from earlier literary genres.

open book. smallThe taproot of all modern romances, westerns included, traces back to nineteenth century authors of romantic fiction such as Jane Austin and the Brontë sisters. Their books are noted for commentary upon social conditions of their time. Some of their stories do not end happily, as do most modern romances, but they contain strong romantic themes.

The other main root of WR leads directly back to those shoot-’em-up westerns I read as a kid. That said, there is a great difference between traditional westerns and western romances. Westerns focus mainly on male characters; female characters are often little more than props. Western romances, on the other hand, usually tell the stories from a woman’s point of view, although the men also possess strong voices. The plots may be action-packed (mine are) but they are largely character driven. Both the hero and heroine reveal their inner struggles as the story unfolds.

Rider on mesa. smallQuoting Constance Martin from a 1999 piece she wrote for  Romantic Times, “Heroes in these novels seek adventure and are forced to conquer the unknown. They are often loners, slightly uncivilized, and ‘earthy.’ Their heroines are often forced to travel to the frontier by events outside their control. These women must learn to survive in a man’s world, and, by the end of the novel, have conquered their fears with love. In many cases the couple must face a level of personal danger, and, upon surmounting their troubles, are able to forge a strong relationship for the future.”

In a western romance the man and woman stand as equal partners by the conclusion of the book. The men don’t dominate the scene as they do in traditional westerns. This is, of course, a very modern outlook, and it may not reflect the reality of late nineteenth century life on the American frontier. But, you know what, when I was a little girl watching those old westerns with my dad, I wasn’t dreaming of being the cowboy hero. I wanted to be the gal riding off into the sunset next to him. The key words there are “next to” – not a horse’s length behind him.

So, if the books I read and write offer a somewhat romanticized view of the Old West, that’s fine with me. After all, we call them western romances, and that’s what we love about them, right ladies?

Okay, that’s my rant for the day. Tune in next time for Suzie’s take on authors, then and now.

13 comments on “Western Romance, The Story of Us – Part II

  1. lifewith4cats

    I enjoyed reading about how you came to love westerns. Dads always hold a special place in our heart like that and influence us in ireversible ways. 🙂


    • texasdruids

      Yes, dads and moms influence us in ways we don’t even realize, many times throughout our lives. I know mine have. Thanks for stopping by!


  2. Pingback: Moonlight Deception is off to the Publisher! « …At Your Fingertips

  3. I liked reading your post-really enjoy reading about the west and cowboy’s. Its funny I lived all my life in a town outside of chicago,a north shore suburb-rich area, nothing wrong with it but I’d go to Libertyville,Grayslake and that was know for west, and thats where country and cowboys lived and this one guy,(were still friends) nickmaned me country slick,but I liked the song by Toby Keith “Shoulda been a cowboy” for thats me-I don’t have any horses but have friends who do and I have a few farm animals on my plot of the country,love it so keep writing western books.


    • texasdruids

      Glad you stopped by, Carole. When “The West” gets in our blood, it’s forever. I also lived near chicago for a few years (in Schaumburg) before moving to Texas. I loved the area and the friends I made there, but Fort Worth is now home. I can’t imagine living anywhere else. It’s “where the west begins.”


  4. Loved your post, Lyn. Am going to promote it to facebook visitors because you do a great job of telling how it all began. I love western romances because in reality in the Old West, women often stepped into a man’s role out of necessity–economic or survival–and found they were quite good at running cattle or a business. Definitely an interesting time.


    • texasdruids

      Thanks so much, Anne. I and my guest bloggers greatly appreciate your support.


  5. Ah, yes, Lyn, my dad influenced my love of westerns as well. Together, we watched lots of TV westerns. A great post, short and concise, touching on the basic history of fictional romance and how the western romance evolved. I agree that most of the historical western romances (at least, the ones I like to read and write) are character driven. On that note, I’ve always felt that the rugged frontiers, historic towns, majestic mountains,rolling foothills, vast plains and endless horizons are practically “romanctic characters” themselves and another reason I love the genre. Thanks again for heading up this great blog series!


    • texasdruids

      Thank you! I’m happy to know you’re enjoying the series. You’re so right about the western landscape, and what a perfect way to put it. I especially agree about the mountains. They are like a living force. The first time I viewed the rockies, they left me speechless. And they still do!


  6. Loved the history Lyn. I love Western Romance and wish I could find more of it. Sadly publishers seem to wish they lived in England. But frankly I’d take a real man in a cowboy hat over some high-born lord any day!


    • texasdruids

      Thanks, Shar. Coming from someone who is such a stickler about accurate research, that is high praise. And me too on the cowboy!


  7. Excellent post, Lyn! Loved it! And that’s exactly why we read and write westerns!


    • texasdruids

      Amen to that, Suzie! Whether as a reader or a writer, there’s nothing as enthralling as a gallop across the Old West with characters we’ve come to love. I don’t know what I’d do without ’em.


I welcome honest replies! Spam will be trashed.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: